Tonight was the last scheduled meeting of the GUHSD Bond Advisory
Commission.
Commission members in attendance were:
Mark Price, Commission Chair,
Julie Wiley, Facilities & Curriculum Chair,
Jim Peabody, Facilities & Curriculum Vice Chair,
James Perkins, Finance Chair,
Patrick Waters, Finance Co-Chair,
Tony Carmara, Repairs & Renovations Chair,
Mendy Brant, Repairs & Renovations Vice Chair,
Bill Garrett, Site Subcommittee Chair.
We had a quorum with each Subcommittee represented.
At tonight's meeting the Commission unanimously voted Patrick
Waters, who has been a Non-Voting Co-Chair of the Finance
Subcommittee, to a voting member of the Finance Subcommittee and
Commission.
In addition, each Subcommittee presented their Final Reports. Each
Report was discussed, voted on, and approved. The Facilities &
Curriculum and Repairs & Renovation Reports received very minor
editing. Each Report received a unanimous vote with the exception
of the Finance Subcommittee's Report. The Finance Subcommittee's
Final Report received all ayes with one abstention. Mendy Brant
abstained because she wanted more time to review the Report. The
Finance Subcommittee Report was submitted to the Commission members
earlier the same day.
The Commission also discussed the format for the GUHSD Board
presentation. It was agreed that Mark Price would provide an
introduction which will include a history of the Commission's
activities. Followed by the Final Reports presented by the Chair of
each of the Subcommittees. Mark Price will provide concluding
remarks to include an overview of the recommendations and some
additional Commission recommendations. The entire Commission will
then be available for questions. It is the hope that the GUHSD
Board of Trustees will vote to support and adopt the Commission's
Final Report.
One of the recommendations of the Commission will be, should the
Final Report be adopted, the Grossmont Union District will have
regular quarterly public Board reviews to determine the status of
the Commission's recommendations. Another one of the Final
Recommendations will be, should the Board adopt the Commission's
Final report, the Commission could remain in force to serve as a
reviewing body; It would review the Districts quarterly Status
Report on the Commission's recommendations and then comment.
5-20-07 - Drafts of the Final Reports for the Facilities &
Curriculum, Repair & Renovation & Site Subcommittees have been posted on
their web pages. The Finance Subcommittee is reviewing the Reports
for any financial issues which they may need to include in their Report.
The Finance Subcommittee Report will be posted after their review.
These Reports will remain in Draft status until the Commission reviews
and votes on them at our last meeting on May 28th.
5-15-07 - The Final Commission meeting has been scheduled for
Monday, May 28, 2007 at 6:00pm at Alpine Elementary School, Alpine, CA.
Please note that this is a change, the meeting was originally scheduled
for May 22, 2007. There will be NO meeting on May 22nd. The
purpose of this meeting is to approve the Final Reports. The Final
Reports will be presented to the Grossmont Board of Trustees at their
June 14, 2007 meeting.
5-14-07 - Posted Draft Final Report for Repair &
Renovation & Site. Also posted 5-15-07 Meeting Notice & Agenda for
Facilities & Curriculum. See respective websites.
5-11-07 - At last night's regular meeting of the GUHSD
Board of Trustees they voted on 5 recommendations put forward by the
GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission Finance Subcommittee. All 5 were passed
by the Board. This represents a positive sign that the District wants
to work together and fully embrace the new paradigm that in order to
accomplish and keep all of the promises made in the Prop H Bond the
District would have to work together. Tonight was a very positive move
in this direction.
The District staff reported on the Bond and actions
taken thus far. They presented a slide that made it clear that they
believe it was going to cost nearly $600 million dollars to keep all the
promises they made in the Bond. I spoke to this point and stated that
even if you pull the high school (approx $100 million dollar expense,
according to District projections) out of the list, the District would
still be, by their own numbers, nearly $100 million dollars short. In
other words they would need an additional $100 million dollars just to
keep the repair and renovation promises they have made.
It would require additional funding, an
additional bond, just to meet the repair and renovation promises. Based
on the Districts past record of passing bonds, it is highly unlikely
that they would pass another bond if the District is divided.
Therefore, to keep the repair and renovation promises
they need to keep the district in harmony. The only way they can retain
and or build harmony is to move forward, proactively and in good faith
on all the promises made; the repair and renovation as well as the new
high school. Therefore, I view tonight's meeting, and tonight's
embracing of the 5 GUHSD BAC recommendations as a positive step in the
right direction.
The following are the 5 recommendations. It is
important to note that the Board modified the recommendations, but the
modifications were accepted by the GUHSD BAC Finance Subcommittee:
Revised Recommendation #1: On or prior to May 30,
2007, the Board shall establish, and thereafter properly maintain, a
segregated reserve fund dedicated solely to (i) the construction of the
12th high school, and (ii) enumerated Repairs & Renovations that, as of
today, will not be commenced prior to December 31, 2008. The reserve
fund shall initially be capitalized with $65 million and shall have
accumulating interest and additional funds added, without subtraction,
so that a total reserve fund of $100 million is achieved by or before
December 31, 2008. On or about December 31, 2008, the Board shall make
a final decision on how to allocate the reserve fund toward Proposition
H mandates including whether to combine the fund with additional monies
obtained, or to be obtained, from an extension bond if approved by the
voters.
Commission Recommendation #2: The District should
divide Phase 3B into “new” 3B and a 3C. Phase 3C would consist of the
last one-third of the projects considered from a priority importance.
It would certainly include those projects presently in Phase 3B that
were not listed in the bond text.
Commission Recommendation #3: Appoint an Independent
Project Construction Expert (“PCE”) that Reports Directly to the Board.
Commission Recommendation #4: The Board should
accept that a “paradigm shift” needs to take place, along with the
appointment of a PCE, in evaluating and implementing a creative
execution for 3 major discrete Prop H components. They should thus
embrace the following initiatives immediately:
Commission Recommendation #5: As soon as possible
the Board should implement a website schedule that tracks the
construction phases and percentage of completion to allow the greatest
amount of transparency to voters and District employees and parents.
The 5 recommendations along with GUHSD Staff
recommendations are available at the Commission website on the Finance
Subcommittee page - Finance Subcommittee webpage -
Click
here
5-9-07 - See The Finance Subcommitte Webpage for the addition of
a Section "Memos". Also, you will find under Reports a Revised BAC
Recommendation for our Recommendation # 1 - 12th High School Reserve
Fund.
5-8-07 - Please visit the following webpages for newly posted
Reports:
Finance Subcommittee
- 4 new Reports responding to GUHSD Staff recommendations on the BAC
Finance Subcommittee Recommendations to the GUHSD Board at the Special
Meeting on April 16th.
Click here
Site Subcommittee -
Draft Final Report.
Click here
5-5-07 - The following is my response to an e-mail from Scott
Patterson regarding GUHSD staff's recommendations of the GUHSD Bond
Advisory Commission's Finance Subcommittee:
"Scott, Thank you
for the information. I am waiting for comments from Jim & Patrick
before a final comment is made on your Board recommendations. I do have
one overriding concern; the language you use implies that there has been
no decision made on the 12th high school. The Commission takes the
position that the decision to build the 12th high school has been made.
It was made when it was included and sold to the public in the Bond.
The only major questions that remain regarding the 12th high school are:
* Where it will be built
* It's size
* How to structure paying for it
The Commission has a problem with any
and all inferences that the 12th high school is merely a possibility.
When the Commission releases its Final Report the Grossmont board and
District will have a "road map" to achieving all the promises made in
the Bond. When the Commission refers to a needed paradigm shift it is
referencing in great part the need for the District to embrace the
concept that all of the promises made in the Bond will be met. I
would like to make a recommendation that the language in your
recommendations regarding the Commissions preliminary Finance
Subcommittee recommendations be edited to reflect an embracing of the
paradigm shift. Thank you for all of your efforts and ongoing support
of the Commission, Respectfully, Mark Price"
4-26-07 - It has been brought to my attention that some are
having trouble opening some of the PDF File links. It looks as
though the problem may be the version of the PDF Reader being used.
If you are having trouble opening a PDF link, please go to the Adobe
Acrobat Reader website and download the newest version - it is free.
http://www.adobe.com/products/reader/
4-16-07 -
Letter to San Diego Taxpayer Association in response to letter dated
4/9/07 (below) - Click Here
4-12-07 -
Agenda for the GUHSD Special Meeting - April 16,
2007
4-9-07 -
Letter to Grossmont Union High School District
Governing Board - Click Here
"You may recall that in 2005, our Association communicated our concerns
regarding the CBOC to the Governing Board and Superintendent. Since
then, the District has made limited progress and we believe there is
still significant room for improvement..." Author: Lani Lutar
4-5-07 - The GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission will present a status
report at a Special Meeting of the GUHSD Board of Trustees on Monday,
April 16, 2007 at 6:00pm. The meeting will be held at the East
County Regional Education Center (ECREC) 924 East Main Street, El Cajon,
CA 92020.
3-29-07 - The GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission held it's second
meeting. At the meeting the Subcommittees reported on the status
and recommendations to date. Please see the individual
Subcommittee pages (links on the left) for specifics and links to the
Reports.
3-8-07 - The GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission's Site Subcommittee
addressed the GUHSD Board of Trustees at the request of the Board.
The Site Subcommittee presented it's recommendations for three sites to
be considered for the twelfth high school.
2-21-07 - The first meeting of the GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission was held on
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 at Alpine Elementary School. The purpose of
the meeting was to introduce the Commission members, provide an overview
of the Commission's goals and responsibilities and set the tone for the
process.
Mark Price opened the meeting by welcoming those in attendance and
introducing the staff and Board members from Grossmont. He then provided
an overview of the Commissions responsibilities. He pointed out that
this is a rare opportunity, "It is not often that a government entity
welcomes and invites the recommendations of the taxpayers after they
already have their money." He also pointed out that the focus of the
Commission must be the entire District, "We in Alpine must understand
that the repair and renovation portion of the Bond is just as important
as the 12th high school portion. And those in the District who are
focused on the repair and renovation portion of the Bond need to accept
that the 12th high school carries equal weight and is as important. We
must be willing to work together for the entire district to turn the
promises made in the Bond to promises kept. We must be willing to set
personal agendas aside and work together for the sake of the kids." He
pointed out that there is a short period of time to address these
issues, "We have less than 100 days to report back to the Grossmont
Board of Trustees with our set of recommendations. What happens now is
up to us. We can choose to spend the next 100 days complaining, pointing
fingers and affixing blame or we can choose to roll up our sleeves and
develop a credible set of recommendations. It's up to us. In some ways,
this may be our last best opportunity."
Mark then introduced the Commission members. The Commission members each
had an opportunity to introduce themselves and describe their vision for
the Commission generally and their Subcommittee specifically.
Then the approximately 75 people in attendance were given the
opportunity to share their thoughts and concerns with the Commission
members and the representatives from Grossmont.
Mark then encouraged all in attendance to sign-up for the Subcommittee(s)
of their choice stating that, "The world is run by those who show up."
The next Commission meeting will be on March 29, 2007.
Subcommittee Updates
Facilities
& Curriculum
The Facilities & Curriculum Subcommittee will
work with the community to determine the type of school and variety of
curriculum possibilities which would best serve their needs. There has
been a great deal of discussion in the Alpine area regarding a full and
comprehensive high school. One goal of the Subcommittee will be to
define full and comprehensive. The Subcommittee would also discuss
further the above-mentioned joint and shared-use opportunities.
3-29-07 -
Please go to the
Facilities & Curriculum page for Reports and updates.
Finance
The Finance Subcommittee will investigate all possible funding options
for the 12th high school as well as the remaining repairs and
renovations as outlined in the Bond. They will be instructed to review
ongoing bond expenditures and investigate all available State matching
funds as well as any other possible sources. They will present to the
Commission all possible funding sources and options.
3-29-07
- At the GUHSD Bond Advisory Commission on March 29, 2007 the Finance
Subcommittee presented it's status report. The Report included the
subcommittees findings and recommendations. Please see
Finance Subcommittee page
for links to the Reports presented.
Repairs &
Renovation
The Repair & Renovation Subcommittee will work with the long list of
needed repairs and renovations as listed in the Bond. They will
prioritize those remaining items and, working with the Finance
Subcommittee and District staff, will attempt to place a cost on each of
the repairs and renovations. Please see
Repairs &
Renovation Subcommittee page for links to the Reports presented and
Agendas & Minutes.
Site
The Site Subcommittee will be tasked to look at the 4 sites presently
before the Board and any and all other possible sites. They will narrow
the list and make a recommendation to the Commission. Grossmont has been
very vocal in their desire to build a 12th high school with many shared
and joint-use opportunities. Some of the discussed possibilities are
ball fields, swimming pool, library and performance center. There has
also been talk of a possible satellite opportunity working with the
Grossmont Cuyamaca Community College District or our local universities.
The Site Subcommittee will need to recommend property large enough to
meet the needs of these possibilities.
3-29-07 -
Please go to the Site page
for Reports and updates.